Top10.NYC Logo
top10.nyc
Top 10 NYC Restaurants with Secret Menus Locals Love

Top 10 NYC Restaurants with Secret Menus Locals Love

This list would spotlight restaurants across NYC that offer off-menu items known mostly to regulars or those in the know. From a hidden burger at a sushi spot to a secret dessert at a downtown café, these culinary secrets add an adventurous twist to dining out.

Jiang Nan NYC
#1

Jiang Nan NYC

103 Bowery, New York, NY 10002, United States

Jiang Nan NYC, located at 103 Bowery, offers a refined take on Chinese cuisine, blending traditional flavors with modern presentation. While their menu is extensive, insiders know to inquire about seasonal specialties and chef’s recommendations that aren’t listed. These off-menu items often showcase the chef’s creativity and the freshest ingredients available, providing a unique dining experience for those in the know.
Zaytinya
#2

Zaytinya

1185 Broadway, New York, NY 10001, United States

Situated at 1185 Broadway, Zaytinya brings the vibrant flavors of the Eastern Mediterranean to New York City. While their menu is comprehensive, regular patrons suggest asking the staff about any special dishes or variations that might not be listed. The knowledgeable staff is often willing to accommodate requests, offering a personalized dining experience that goes beyond the standard offerings.
Carbone New York
#3

Carbone New York

181 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Located at 181 Thompson Street, Carbone is a celebrated Italian-American restaurant that pays homage to the mid-20th-century dining experience. Beyond their renowned spicy rigatoni vodka and veal parmesan, Carbone is known for off-menu items like Mario’s Meatballs, made with sweet Italian sausage and milk-soaked bread, fried and then slow-cooked in a flavorful tomato sauce. These hidden gems are often shared by word of mouth among regulars and add an exclusive touch to the dining experience.
Gramercy Tavern
#4

Gramercy Tavern

42 E 20th St, New York, NY 10003, United States

Situated at 42 E 20th Street, Gramercy Tavern is a New York institution known for its seasonal American cuisine and warm hospitality. While the restaurant offers a set menu, those in the know often ask about the off-menu burger, available during lunch hours. This burger, made with a blend of brisket, short rib, and chuck, topped with cheddar and house-made bacon, is a hidden delight for burger enthusiasts.
Banter NYC
#5

Banter NYC

169 Sullivan St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Located at 169 Sullivan Street, Banter NYC is a cozy café that offers a modern take on classic brunch fare. While their menu features popular items like avocado toast and grain bowls, regulars suggest inquiring about any special dishes or variations that might not be listed. The friendly staff is often accommodating, providing personalized recommendations to enhance your dining experience.
Boucherie Union Square
#6

Boucherie Union Square

225 Park Ave S, New York, NY 10003, United States

Situated at 225 Park Avenue South, Boucherie Union Square is a French steakhouse known for its classic dishes and elegant ambiance. While their menu is extensive, patrons often recommend asking about the chef’s specials or any off-menu items that might be available. These hidden offerings can include unique cuts of meat or seasonal dishes that showcase the chef’s creativity.
Ci Siamo
#7

Ci Siamo

440 W 33rd St Suite #100, New York, NY 10001, United States

Located at 440 W 33rd Street, Ci Siamo is an Italian restaurant that emphasizes wood-fired cooking and seasonal ingredients. While their menu is thoughtfully curated, diners are encouraged to ask about any off-menu specials or chef’s recommendations. These exclusive dishes often highlight the freshest ingredients and the chef’s innovative techniques.
San Marzano
#8

San Marzano

117 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003, United States

Situated at 117 2nd Avenue, San Marzano is a casual Italian eatery known for its fresh pasta and affordable prices. While their menu offers a variety of classic dishes, regulars suggest inquiring about any off-menu pasta creations or daily specials that the chef might be offering. These hidden gems provide an opportunity to experience unique flavor combinations and the chef’s culinary creativity.
CHELI MANHATTAN 浙里
#9

CHELI MANHATTAN 浙里

19 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003, United States

Located at 19 St Marks Place, CHELI MANHATTAN offers authentic Jiangnan cuisine in a setting that evokes the elegance of the Song Dynasty. While their menu is rich with traditional dishes, patrons are encouraged to ask about any off-menu items or chef’s specials that might be available. These exclusive offerings often showcase rare ingredients or traditional recipes not commonly found on the standard menu.
Carmine's - Time Square
#10

Carmine's - Time Square

200 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, United States

Situated at 200 W 44th Street, Carmine’s is a family-style Italian restaurant known for its generous portions and classic dishes. While their menu is extensive, regulars often recommend asking the staff about any off-menu items or special preparations that might be available. These hidden options can include unique pasta dishes or variations of classic recipes tailored to the diner’s preferences.

Related Lists

Top 10 Brunch Spots That Feel Like Spring in NYC

Top 10 Brunch Spots That Feel Like Spring in NYC

Places with sun-drenched patios, floral vibes, and fresh, bright menus.

Best Pizza Spots

Best Pizza Spots

The most authentic and delicious pizza joints in NYC

Best breakfast in the East Village

Best breakfast in the East Village

Breakfast places in town top rated